(231) 944-6541
West: 
This might be the most important sentence I write on this blog all year, so read it twice.
You are not required to go to the physical therapy clinic your surgeon recommends.
I know that might feel strange to read. Maybe it even feels a little disloyal. Your surgeon is a skilled professional who has invested significantly in your care. Surely they know best where you should go for PT?
Possibly. But possibly not. And you deserve to make that decision deliberately, with real information, rather than by default.
How the referral system actually works
Many orthopedic surgeons — not all, but many — have a financial relationship with a physical therapy clinic. Some own equity stakes in a PT practice. Some operate affiliated clinics within the same health system. Some simply have referral relationships that generate volume for a clinic they work closely with.
None of this is secret, and none of it is inherently wrong. But it creates an incentive structure that doesn't always point in the same direction as your best clinical outcome.
High-volume PT clinics — the kind that receive large numbers of surgical referrals — are typically optimized for throughput. What that often looks like in practice: shorter one-on-one time with the supervising PT, more time with aides or assistants, less individualized program design, and less of the hands-on manual therapy that addresses the scar tissue and soft tissue restrictions that significantly affect outcomes.
I'm not saying every surgeon-affiliated clinic delivers poor care. Some are excellent. I'm saying you shouldn't assume quality on the basis of a referral.
Michigan direct access — you have rights
Michigan is a direct-access state for physical therapy. Since 2015, Michigan law has allowed you to start PT without a physician referral — a PT can evaluate and treat you for up to 21 days or 10 visits before a physician needs to be involved. One honest caveat: most insurance plans, including Medicare, still require a physician to sign off on your plan of care for visits to be covered. In practice, that's paperwork your PT clinic handles behind the scenes.
Here's what direct access really means for you: when a surgeon hands you a referral at discharge, that referral is a recommendation about where to go. It is not a requirement. You are free to take it to any PT clinic you choose.
That's your legal right. Exercise it.
The five questions to ask any PT clinic
Before you commit to a clinic for your hip replacement recovery — whether it's the one on the referral or one you researched yourself — ask these five questions directly.
1. Will I see the same physical therapist at every visit? Continuity of care is not a luxury; it's a clinical necessity. If the answer is "usually" or "we try to" — that's a red flag.
2. Is my therapist a Doctor of Physical Therapy, or a PT assistant or aide? These are very different credentials with very different scopes of practice. A DPT has completed a doctoral program and is qualified to evaluate, diagnose, and design your treatment. An aide has no clinical degree. Ask who will actually be in the room with you, session after session.
3. Do you specialize in post-surgical hip recovery? The assessment protocols, exercise progressions, and manual therapy involved in hip replacement recovery are not the same as general outpatient PT.
4. What does my home program look like between sessions? You'll come to PT twice a week. The other five days are yours, and what you do during them matters enormously. A vague answer — "we give you exercises to do at home" — is not good enough.
5. Do you accept Medicare? If you are on Medicare or plan to be, confirm this upfront.
Red flags to watch for
Watch for large treatment gyms with multiple patients exercising at once under limited supervision. Watch for the majority of your session spent with a technician while the PT briefly checks in. Watch for exercise programs that never change or progress. Watch for clinicians who can't explain why you're doing an exercise — only what it is. Watch for programs that never look past the replaced joint.
Any of these patterns suggests a clinic optimized for volume rather than outcomes.
How to have this conversation with your surgeon
Raising this with your surgeon can feel awkward. Here's a simple way to frame it: "I've been doing some research on physical therapy options for my recovery. Is the clinic on my referral the only option, or am I able to choose another provider?"
A good surgeon will tell you directly that you have a choice. A surgeon who becomes defensive about this question is, frankly, giving you additional information worth considering.
The truth: the PT clinic you choose will have more impact on your outcome after hip replacement than almost any other decision in your recovery. You are not required to go where your surgeon refers you. Choose deliberately.
Your next step
Put us through the same test. Call (231) 944-6541, ask us the five questions from this article, and then come see for yourself — a free 20-minute Hip Assessment with a Doctor of Physical Therapy at Superior Physical Therapy costs you nothing but the drive. If we're not the right fit, you'll still leave knowing exactly what to look for somewhere else.
And if you want the complete plan — before, during, and after surgery — my book, The Complete Guide to Your Hip Replacement, walks you through all of it. You can get a copy free here.
